What do the AI tools themselves say?
We asked ChatGPT, Claude and Google AI Mode this question on 13 November 2026. ChatGPT said you don't necessarily need an agency and suggested learning the basics yourself first. Claude said most small and mid-size businesses can do it themselves. Google AI Mode listed DIY steps and gave two reasons to hire: limited time, and measuring results across several AI tools.
We agree with all three. We sell this service, and we still think DIY is the right call for plenty of owners. Every step we do for clients is written out in our guides for exactly that reason.
The DIY checklist
Do these in order. The first block is one-off work. The second block is the part that keeps working.
One-off setup (a few weekends)
- Write down 5 to 10 questions a customer would ask before hiring you. Include your city: "best roofer in Raleigh for storm damage," "how much does Botox cost in Tampa."
- Run each one in a logged-out ChatGPT session and in Google AI Mode. Screenshot who is named today. This is your baseline.
- Claim and complete your Google Business Profile. Name, address, phone, hours, categories and services must match your website exactly.
- Claim Bing Places and verify your site in Bing Webmaster Tools. OpenAI says ChatGPT search partners with other search providers and points to Microsoft's privacy statement for how they handle queries. Our guide on why ChatGPT search runs on Bing has the steps.
- Check your robots.txt allows OAI-SearchBot. OpenAI says sites that opt out of OAI-SearchBot will not be shown in ChatGPT search answers.
- Make sure Google can index your key pages. Google says that to appear in AI Overviews or AI Mode, a page must be indexed and eligible to be shown in Google Search with a snippet. There is no special AI markup to add.
- Give each service its own page, with a plain answer near the top: what it is, who it is for, the price range, and your city.
- Add LocalBusiness structured data that matches what the page says. See our schema guide.
- Claim your business in ChatGPT's Business Hub. OpenAI's setup page explains it. Note that local stores and restaurants can currently claim only an existing US listing, and claiming does not guarantee more visibility.
- Fix your listings on the directories that show up as sources when you run your questions.
Every month (a few hours)
- Ask every customer for a review, every time. Ask them to mention the service by name. Our guide on the reviews AI reads explains why.
- Publish 2 to 4 pages that answer real customer questions.
- Check that your hours, phone and services are still the same everywhere.
- Rerun your questions on the same day each month, logged out, and save dated screenshots.
The full walkthrough is in how to get your business recommended by ChatGPT.
When is DIY enough?
- You have a few hours every month and you will actually spend them.
- Your city has few competitors who are doing this work.
- When you run your questions, the answers name small local businesses, not national chains.
- You are comfortable editing your website, or someone on your team is.
- You do not mind waiting longer while you learn.
If most of these are true, start yourself. You can always hire later, and the work you did will not be wasted.
When does an agency make sense?
- Time. The one-off work is satisfying. The monthly part is where most owners stop, and it is the part that compounds.
- Competition. If three other businesses in your city are already being named, you need faster, steadier work to move them.
- Measurement. Running the same questions on several tools, the same way, every two weeks, is tedious. An agency should do it and show you screenshots.
- Risk. A good agency puts something on the line. Ours is written in our guarantee: if you are not "recommended (in the top 3) for at least 3 of your 5 questions on ChatGPT or Google AI Mode by day 90," you choose every dollar back or free work until you are.
What does each option really cost?
DIY costs close to nothing in cash and a few hours of your time every month, indefinitely. We charge $999 a month, with a 3-month minimum, then month to month. Our AI visibility cost guide compares that with typical local retainers and lists what any quote should include.
A simple test: what is one new customer worth to you, and how many hours a month is your time worth? If doing it yourself costs you more than a customer or two a month in lost time, paying someone is cheaper.
Method. Anything written here as in our checks is our own observation from running the same buyer questions in ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI Mode in a fresh logged-out session, month after month, most recently in September 2026. Third-party figures are linked in the sources beside this guide. Where a tool's behaviour is documented by the vendor, we describe the documentation rather than our guess at it.