Why do these questions matter?
When we asked ChatGPT, Claude and Google AI Mode what to ask an AI SEO agency, on 13 November 2026, the advice lined up. Ask how they will get the result, how they measure it, and what they report. Distrust promises. Claude added a useful split: some agencies use AI to do SEO, and some optimize for AI answers. Those are different services.
Google gives the same kind of advice for hiring any SEO. Its guide says to ask questions like "What kind of results do you expect to see, and in what timeframe?" and to beware anyone who claims to guarantee rankings (Google Search Central).
12 questions to ask an AI SEO agency
- Do you optimize for AI answers, or use AI to do SEO? You want the first. A good answer names the tools they target, such as ChatGPT and Google AI Mode, and talks about being named in the answer, not just ranking in blue links.
- Which exact questions will you measure? A good answer is a written list of buyer questions with your city in them, agreed with you before work starts. "We track your AI visibility" with no list is a bad answer.
- Which AI tools count? Get the names. If they say "all of them," ask which ones they report on every month. We measure on ChatGPT and Google AI Mode, and treat others as a bonus.
- How do you run the check? Look for a logged-out or fresh session, the same method each time, and the location set to your city where the tool allows it. A logged-in account with history can tilt the answer.
- Can you show me today's answer for my city? This is the most useful question. A serious agency can run two or three of your questions live, in front of you, in a few minutes. It tells you who is named now and whether the agency understands your market.
- What does "recommended" or "visible" mean in your report? Ask for a definition. Named in the answer text? In the top 3? Or just a link in the source list? Ours is written down: one of the first 3 businesses named in the answer, not a source link.
- How often will I see results, and in what form? Dated screenshots on a fixed schedule beat a dashboard score. We send them every 2 weeks.
- What happens if it does not work? Some agencies offer nothing. Some offer free extra months. Some offer cash back. Ask which, and ask for the written terms. Our guide on AI SEO money-back guarantees explains what to check.
- Will you tell me if my market cannot be won? A good agency checks first and declines when a hospital system, a national chain or a long-established competitor owns the answer. If they say yes to everyone, the guarantee, if any, is probably weak.
- Do you work with my competitors in this city? Ask directly. We take one business per industry per city. Other agencies may work with several competitors at once, which is worth knowing before you sign.
- Who owns the website, pages and listings if I leave? You should. Ask about domain, hosting, content and access to your Google Business Profile. Ask how long the handover takes.
- What do you need from me, and how much time will it take? Every honest agency needs something from you: access, approvals, photos, and asking customers for reviews. A good answer is specific. If they say "nothing," ask how they will get real reviews without you.
What answers should make you walk away?
- "We guarantee you will be in ChatGPT." OpenAI says placement is not guaranteed.
- "We can pay to get you in." OpenAI says advertising doesn't influence ChatGPT's independent answers.
- A score with no questions or screenshots behind it.
- A plan built on hundreds of AI-written pages, or bought links and reviews.
- No written terms, or terms they will not send before you pay.
- They will not show you your current answer.
For more on spotting bad offers, see is AI SEO a scam.
How would we answer these?
Briefly, so you can compare. We agree 5 buyer questions with you in writing at kickoff. We measure on ChatGPT and Google AI Mode, in a fresh logged-out session, and send dated screenshots every 2 weeks. "Recommended" means one of the first 3 businesses named in the answer. If you are not recommended for at least 3 of the 5 on either tool by day 90, you choose every dollar back or free work until you are. We decline markets we cannot win. One business per industry per city. Everything we build stays yours. We need access to your website and Google Business Profile, and for you to send our review kit to at least 10 past customers. The price is $999 a month, 3-month minimum, then month to month. The full terms are on our guarantee page and in our Service Terms.
That is how we do it. It is not the only good way. Use the questions on every agency you talk to, including us.
Method. Anything written here as in our checks is our own observation from running the same buyer questions in ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI Mode in a fresh logged-out session, month after month, most recently in September 2026. Third-party figures are linked in the sources beside this guide. Where a tool's behaviour is documented by the vendor, we describe the documentation rather than our guess at it.